ANNUAL REPORT 2010
Your Officers have pleasure in presenting the Annual Report.
The accounts, for twelve months to the 31st December year-end, show a deficit of £2,272. The exceptional performance by the players in reaching the England County finals resulted in an unanticipated cost of £6,961, without that success the accounts would have been in surplus. The accounts show a 6½ % decline in club membership across the County compared to 2009.
The County Card Scheme continues and, in its fifth year, 26 Clubs participated and over nearly 400 members enrolled. This is well short of the sales in other Counties and the scheme will be revised for 2011 to try and make this valuable club-member perk is taken up in greater numbers.
The County Golf Partnership saw more clubs becoming active in recruitment. The County leads the country in the number of clubs having achieved GolfMark and the number working towards it.
The CGP supported club initiatives with £47k for Recruitment and Retention, all funded externally
National talks towards merging the EGU and EWGA are about to result in a proposal to Counties.
The 93rd County Championship Meeting was held at Gay Hill Golf Club, 9th - 10th June.
The Gold Medal – John Hems (Kings Norton) 72 + 70 =142, who also won the Philip Padmore Nett Trophy with 142.
The Bronze Medal – Chris Heeley (Moseley), 70 + 75 =145.
The 54-Hole GD Carr Cup – Chris Nugent (Fulford Heath & Wales), 216
The Tomson-James Cup, competed for by 15 club ‘A’ teams, resulted in a win for Moseley 218, beating The Worcestershire, scoring 220
The Jubilee Shield, competed for by 10 club ‘B’ teams, resulted in a win for Kings Norton 227, with Moseley 2 strokes behind them.
The 61st Worcestershire Open Championship was played at The Worcestershire. Chris Nugent (Fulford Heath & Wales), won the Guy Bigwood Cup with 136, including a course record 64, and the Secretaries Bowl with 281. Danny Clee took 2nd place. David Marshall (The Worcestershire) was third.
The 37th Worcestershire Matchplay Championship was played at Moseley. Richard Sadler (Moseley) won the Derek Greey Cup retaining his title after beating Paul Garey (Kings Norton) in the final.
The 35th Competition for the Droitwich Shield was won by the Moseley ‘A’ team, who beat the Fulford Heath ‘A’ Team in the final.
The 54th Competition for The Boulton Salver was held at Kidderminster on Sunday 30th May, and was won by Mark Dudley and Henry James (Kidderminster) with a nett score of 70 + 71 = 141. Runners up were Luke Towler and Neill Smith (Wharton Park), with a nett score of 147.
The 64th Competition for The Brand Hall Gold Vase was held at Kidderminster on Wednesday 18th August and won by Stourbridge with an aggregate nett score of 288. The team was P Dodson, J Powell, B Swain, P O’Reilly, and J Davidson. Runners-up were Fulford Heath on 292.
The Midland Group Qualifying for the EGU County Championship was held at Lingdale Golf Club on 19th June. Worcestershire was represented by Chris Nugent, Steven Lane, John Hems, Paul Garey, Chris Heeley and Richard Sadler. The Team finished in 1st place out of 10, 6 strokes ahead of Runners-Up Warwickshire. The team went to the National Final at Hunstanton and finished in fourth place.
The County Teams. The First Team came 4th, but the Second Team maintained their run of good form by finishing runner-up again to Warwickshire.
|
Friendlies
|
First Team
|
Second Team
|
Midland League
|
First Team
|
Second Team
|
|
Leicestershire
|
Snowed off
|
Snowed off
|
Nottinghamshire
|
Halved (not played)
|
Lost 8 – 10
|
|
Gloucestershire
|
Half 7 ½ - 7 ½
|
Snowed off
|
Shropshire & Herefordshire
|
Loss 6½ – 8½
|
Won 11 – 7
|
|
|
|
|
Derbyshire
|
Won 10 1/2 – 4 1/2
|
Lost 8 – 10
|
|
|
|
|
Staffordshire
|
Half 7 ½ - 7 ½
|
Won 9½ – 8½
|
|
|
|
|
Warwickshire
|
Loss 6 – 9
|
Won 10 – 8
|
The President’s Shield, for most points in First Team League matches, was won by Anthony Hill (Fulford Heath), scoring 4 1/2 points from a possible 6.
The Chandler Shield, for most points in Second Team League matches, was shared by Ben Myatt (Redditch), and Rumayne Stevens (Halesowen) with 4 points from a possible 7 ½.
The Bolton Shield for most points in Senior Team matches, was won by Grenville Rose (Worcester)
The Junior Championship was held at The Vale on 28th July. Matthew Vigurs (Gaudet Luce) 70 + 78 = 148 became Junior U-18 and U-16 Champion taking the Mansell Cup.
Oliver Farrell (Evesham) was Runner-Up with 149 and he was the nett winner, 74 + 75 - 8 = 141, taking the Rigbey Cup.
The Junior Matchplay Champion was George Palmer (Gaudet Luce), beating Matt Vigurs (Gaudet Luce)
The Senior Matchplay was retained by Will Painter, (Kidderminster) who beat Chris Lowry (Blackwell)
The 11th Competition for the Senior Foursomes was held at Worcester on Thursday 28th June and Ken Murton (Worcester) & Tony Jowle (Moseley) won with a score of 75 to win the John Wharrad Trophy Jugs, by one stroke from Brian Morris (Wharton Park) & Willy Kerr (Redditch), runners-up for the second time. Morris and Kerr therefore took The Aberdovey Salvers, for the Nett Winners, with 74-5=69
The 31st Worcestershire Senior Championship was held at Droitwich on the 22nd September. Peter Swinburne (Kings Norton) became Senior Champion, winning the Nevil Carroll Salver with 73, beating Chris Lowry (Blackwell) by three strokes. Also on 76 were Willie Kerr (Redditch), Grenville Rose (Worcester), Will Painter (Kidderminster). The Denis Hayes Salver, for the Nett Winner, was won by Kelvin Price (Droitwich) with 83 – 16 = 67.
The Captain and Guests was played at Stourbridge and won with 44 by the Hagley pairing of Mike Swann and guest, John Palmer. The Rose Hill and Stourbridge were runners-up one point behind.
The R&A Salver Competition for 18 club teams of three medal qualifiers was played at The Worcestershire and won by Bromsgrove, H Mace 71, B Styring 75, C Richards 70 216. They won from The Vale, second, by four strokes and Droitwich third, 223. The best individual score, winning the EGU Salver, was V Collins 85 – 17 = 68. He went on to represent the County in the EGU Gold Medal Competition.
| WORCESTERSHIRE UNION OF GOLF CLUBS |
| MINUTES THE HALF YEAR MEETING OF THE UNION COUNCIL |
| Held at Kings Norton Club at 7.30 p.m. on Tuesday, 12th October 2010 |
|
|
|
|
|
| I. Attendees and Apologies |
| WUGC Representatives |
|
Club Representatives |
|
| Elected Executive Members 9 |
Clubs |
Name |
Position |
| Peter Adams |
President - Council Chairman |
Blackwell |
Finlay Clark |
Secretary/Manager |
| William Thompson |
Exec Chairman/Development Officer |
Blackwell |
Peter Keating |
Captain |
| Rod Armstrong |
Captain |
Bransford |
Dave Randle |
Vice-Captain |
| Steve Wilkins |
Senior Team Captain |
Bransford |
Alan McPherson |
Secretary |
| Darren Smith |
Second Team Captain |
Bromsgrove |
John Brothwood |
Secretary |
| Brian Peplow |
Junior Organiser/Coaching |
Bromsgrove |
Andy Diston |
Captain |
| Roy Hobbis |
MGU Representative |
Cleobury Mortimer |
Richard Chandler |
Captain |
| Chris Gupwell |
Treasurer |
Cleobury Mortimer |
Glen Hawes |
Committee |
| Andrew Boyd |
EGU/MUGU Representative |
Cocks Moors Woods |
Chris Edwards |
President |
| Brian Morris |
President Elect |
Droitwich |
Roger Whiteman |
Vice-Captain |
| |
|
Droitwich |
Clive Allen |
Captain |
| Honarary Members 7 |
Dudley |
John Edwards |
Past Captain |
| Norman Bolton |
Past President |
Dudley |
Stephen Hall |
Vice- Captain |
| Wil Painter |
Vice-President |
Evesham |
Richard Cross |
Vice-Captain |
| Anthony Jowle |
Vice-President |
Evesham |
Jerry Cain |
Secretary |
| Graham Yardley |
Vice-President |
Gaudet Luce |
Stephan Kotlarzewski |
Captain |
| Brenda Smith |
Life Member |
Gaudet Luce |
Andy Waters |
Vice-Captain |
| |
|
Gay Hill |
Roy Sturdy |
Vice-Captain |
| Possible Executive & Honorary Official Votes 16 |
Gay Hill |
Alan Smith |
Captain |
| |
|
Habberley |
John Plant |
Captain |
| Non-Voting Co-Opted Executive Members 1 |
Habberley |
Mike Beard |
Vice-President |
| Apology |
|
Hagley |
Graham Yardley |
Hon Sec |
| Chris Augousti |
Co-opted Executive Member |
Hagley |
Mike Swan |
Captain |
| |
|
Halesowen |
Steve Collins |
Captain |
| Non-Voting Minute Secretary 1 |
Halesowen |
Brian Stokes |
President |
| Jo Gupwell |
Minutes Secretary |
Kidderminster |
Alan Stanyer |
Captain |
| |
|
Kidderminster |
Malcolm Pritchard |
Secretary |
| APOLOGIES |
|
Kings Norton |
Terry Webb |
Secretary |
| Past President, Vice-President & Executive |
Kings Norton |
Alan Cowin |
Captain |
| Douglas Humphries |
Past President |
Moseley |
Ian Warner |
Comps Chairman |
| Denis Hayes |
Past President |
Redditch |
T Humphries |
Chairman |
| John Moreton |
Past President |
Redditch |
Willie Kerr |
Secretary |
| Jeffery Adams |
Vice-President |
Redditch Kingfisher |
Ray Barnett |
Secretary |
| David Rodway |
Vice-President |
Stourbridge |
Mark Hughes |
Secretary |
| Jim Gray |
Vice-President |
The Abbey Hotel & GC |
George Pagan |
Past Secretary |
| Matthew Houghton |
Vice-President |
The Abbey Hotel & GC |
David Steane |
Secretary |
| David McDermott |
CMS Manager |
The Vale |
Les Seal |
Captain |
| Club Apologies |
4 |
The Vale |
Clive Werrett |
Secretary |
| Churchill & Blakedown |
Ombersley |
The Worcestershire |
Terry Smith |
Secretary/Manager |
| Fulford Heath |
North Worcestershire |
Wharton Park |
David Richards |
Captain |
| ABSENTEES |
9 Clubs |
Wharton Park |
Steven Harvey |
Secretary |
| Clubs |
|
Worcester |
Derek Turner |
Treasurer |
| Bewdley Pines |
Ravenmeadow |
|
|
|
| Brandhall |
Rose Hill |
|
|
|
| Little Lakes |
Rowley Regis |
|
|
|
| Perdiswell |
Warley Woods |
Number of Clubs Present |
24 |
| |
Wyre Forest |
Possible Club Votes to be Cast |
48 |
2. Minutes of the Annual Council Meeting held on Tuesday 13 April 2010 as circulated were taken as read, confirmed and signed.
3. Matters Arising not covered elsewhere:
3.1. (Item 10.3.) In response to a question from Mr Brian Stokes of Halesowen about the result of discussions with Mr Andy Maine of Wyre Forest, the Secretary advised that the Club had been contacted and invited to ask the Chairman and Secretary to one of their meetings to discuss the matter. Mr Maine has since retired and his replacement has not yet dealt with the matter.
3.2. (Item 8.4.) Mr Graham Yardley of Hagley asked for information about the current position with regard to the VAT issue. The Secretary advised that no tribunal had yet taken place and no date has been set for this. The EGU are keen to deal with this matter and have made contact with other countries where similar rules apply.
3.3. (Item 8.2.) Mr Graham Yardley of Hagley asked about the current position with regard to the Central Database of Handicaps. The Secretary advised that every Club in the County was up and running with just one exception. The Clubs are now registered and their players numbered. The exchange of scores between Clubs is happening automatically.
4. Captain’s Report: The Captain reported that in the League the season had started badly with a disappointing loss against Shropshire & Herefordshire with a performance from the Team that was not to as high a standard as hoped for. The win in the second match against Derbyshire was the best result so far with Chris Nugent making his first appearance of the year. There were a number of great performances from members of the Team which led to a very satisfying result. The third match against Staffordshire was halved, followed by a loss in the fourth match against Warwickshire which meant the Team had lost all chance of winning the League. The last match of the season against Nottinghamshire was a wash out and is still to be played, with the Team currently in third place in the League. The Captain went on to say that the highlight of the year was winning the Midlands Qualifier, a fantastic achievement considering the last success was 44 years ago. Chris Nugent equaled the course record with a score of 67. The Captain had been particularly pleased with the way in which the team played the afternoon round with everyone showing great character. The Team then went on to Hunstanton. where they finished in fourth place with play taking place in horrendous conditions. The Captain advised that he believed that the extra money invested in the teams had helped them to reach these high levels. He said that the players were proud to represent the County and appreciated the investment made in them. He thanked the clubs for their hospitality and support.
In conclusion the Captain said that he had now come to the end of his reign which he had greatly enjoyed. He thanked the Executive for all their encouragement.
The President thanked Rod Armstrong for all he had done during his two years as the most successful Captain for 44 years.
5. Second Team Captain’s Report: The Second Team Captain advised that at the beginning of the season it had been decided to include a number of younger players in the team to progress their development. Two young players in particular, Henry James, Kidderminster, and Ben Myatt, Redditch, had been a credit to the County and there had been good support from six other under 18 players. The first match against Staffordshire had resulted in a win, as had the match away against Warwickshire which was considered to be a very good achievement. The match against Nottinghamshire had been played in horrendous weather conditions and was lost under unfortunate circumstances. The Second Team Captain advised that there was still a mathematical chance of the Team winning the League, but he did not really think this very likely.
The President thanked Darren Smith for his hard work over the last two years.
6. Senior Team Captain’s Report: The Senior Team Captain began his report by saying that the Seniors play in a spirit of friendship. They had had a good season, playing ten matches, of which they won four, lost five and halved one. As all Seniors’ matches are played during the week it has sometimes been difficult to get the best team out because of work commitments. The Seniors’ Team Captain expressed his thanks to the stalwarts who have been playing Seniors’ golf for a number of years and who will always turn up at short notice in an emergency. A plea was made to those present to ask the Seniors in their Clubs to come forward and become part of the Seniors squad. In conclusion the Senior Team Captain thanked the Executive and the Secretary for organizing the fixtures and all those who had supported him during the year.
The President thanked Steve Wilkins for his hard work in his first year at Senior Team Captain.
7. Report by the Junior Organiser and Coaching Officer:
a) Junior Organiser: Mr Brian Peplow advised that the Juniors had had another excellent season at all levels. The season had started well by winning the Midland Boys’ Four Counties where all three matches were won for the first time for 40 years. This was followed by a win in the first League match against Warwickshire. Unfortunately due to injuries and Tom Warbrick turning professional it had not been possible to field the strongest team in any of the following League games, losing to Staffordshire and Derbyshire and halving the match against Shropshire and Herefordshire. The Under 16s Team won the triangular tournament against Staffordshire and Shropshire and Herefordshire by a record margin. In their friendly matches the Under 16s won all three. Turning to individual Junior successes, Mr Peplow advised that Rob Aldred, Stourbridge, had won the Midland Boys Championship, Matt Vigurs, Gaudet Luce, had won the Under 18s and Under 16s Championship and Oliver Farrell, Evesham, had won the Under 14s Championship. George Palmer, Gaudet Luce, is the Under 18 Matchplay Champion. Mr Peplow thanked Graham Farr, the County Head Coach, for his encouragement of Junior golfers. Three players have now been invited to have EGU coaching and become part of the England squad. Mr Peplow also thanked Mike O’Mahoney and Mark Ralphs for their help during the season, all parents and members of the Executive who had supported the teams and finally all the Clubs who had provided facilities for Junior matches.
b) County Coaching: Mr Brian Peplow gave details the selection process that had taken place last Autumn in order to appoint a Head County Coach, resulting in the appointment of Graham Farr. Coaching for the year has been for players at all levels with a pathway approach through the Juniors to the First Team. A big difference has been seen in the coaching scene which has resulted in a successful season. Mr Peplow advised that coaching will start much earlier this year. On the question of the coaching budget, Mr Peplow advised that this had been cut this year, but that next year he would like to increase the funding to provide more coaching. He advised that he will be trying to contact all Clubs with a view to finding more players for the Junior squads. Mr Peplow appealed to all Clubs to bring to his attention boys of any age who are making progress but about whom he may not have knowledge. Finally, Mr Peplow thanked the Chairman for his enthusiasm and help during the year, especially in connection with coaching.
The President thanked Brian Peplow for all the extremely hard work he puts into the Junior Section and coaching.
8. Report by the Manager of the County Membership Scheme: In Mr David McDermott’s absence the President reported that the transition from Mr Jeffery Adams as Manager had been seamless and that both meetings had gone very well.
9. Election of the EGU and MGU Representatives for the County: Mr Andrew Boyd had been nominated as the County’s representative at the EGU and he and Mr Roy Hobbis as representatives at the MGU. Carried unanimously.
10. The Equality Act: Mrs Kirstie Thirde, Compliance Officer for the England Golf Partnership, gave a very detailed talk on the impact and implementation of the Act which came into effect on 1 October 2010. She explained how the Act had come into being and exactly what was or was not discrimination about which there has been a degree of confusion. She advised that the provisions under age discrimination will probably come into effect in 2012. Mrs Thirde explained that it is unlawful to discriminate against members, associate members, prospective members and guests on the basis of a protected characteristic, whether directly or indirectly. The protected characteristics listed in the Act are:
Age
Disability
Gender reassignment
Race (including ethnic origin, national origin, colour, nationality)
Religion or belief
Sex
Sexual orientation
Marriage and civil partnerships (Listed at the beginning of the Act, but excluded from Part 7 which deals with Golf Clubs)
Mrs Thirde went on to expand on the various constraints under the Act and followed this up by giving a few examples of common questions raised and the answers to those questions. She went on to take questions from the floor and to give guidance, ending her presentation by giving the warning that if Clubs have not complied with the provisions of the Act (with the exception of the protected characteristic of age) which came into effect on 1 October, they are running the risk of civil litigation which could result in monetary compensation and being compelled by the Court to alter their practices. She referred those present to the EWGA website Hot Topics section where clear guidance can be found.
The President thanked Kirstie Thirde for her very informative talk.
11. Report by the Chairman of the County Golf Partnership: Mr Andrew Boyd reported that the CGP had just submitted their six month summary of progress this year in which it was clear that they had set and achieved their targets.
Junior Academies had been set up with a good pathway taking players through into the Elite squads.
The results of Club responses to a Beginner’s Enquiry had been circulated to all Clubs together with a report on best practice. Some Clubs have an excellent process in place, but this is not true throughout the County. In general Clubs have found this feedback helpful and Mr Boyd advised those who wished to improve their marketing for beginners to contact Mr Warwick Holland.
Mr Boyd reported that 21 Clubs in the County now have GolfMark. Recruitment has not increased at the rate the CGP would have liked and Mr Boyd urged Clubs to contact Warwick Holland for advice on this. He advised that Warwick Holland is also available to consult about contracts of employment and the relationship between the Club and Professional.
12. Secretary’s Report:
12.1. The Secretary advised that the County Dinner will take place on Friday 21 January 2011 and listed the principal guests who would be present.
12.2. The Secretary reported on the setting up and use of large TV screens at Fulford Heath to assist in promoting Club and County matters. He went into the funding of these and advised that he had sent details to all Clubs, but had received only two responses. Fulford Heath has agreed to allow the Union to use their Club for a demonstration of the system and the Secretary will be writing to Clubs to invite them to attend. Mr Graham Yardley advised that they had a rolling screen at Hagley, but he did not feel it was really effective in promoting items. He would prefer the County to send a newsletter out regularly by email to all members. However, the representative from The Abbey Hotel and Golf Club said that there was one at the hotel which he thought was very eye-catching and impressive.
12.3. Reporting on the County Card Scheme, the Secretary advised that sales had increased by 40 to 373, generating £5,000 in the year. He advised that different Clubs had different methods of promoting the scheme resulting in varying levels of cards sold. The Secretary explained that the Union wanted to find another source of funding in addition to the annual club member subscription. Other Counties receive income of between £15,000 and £25,000 per annum from their schemes. The Executive are in the process of setting up a Committee to analyse why there is a shortfall in Worcestershire. The Secretary asked that if Clubs have anyone who could contribute to this Committee they should please come forward and contact him.
13. Subscriptions: The following motions were tabled:
13.1. To approve that for the year 2011 the subscription payable to the WUGC should increase by 75p to £7.25
13.2. To confirm that for the year 2011 the subscription payable to the EGU will increase by 25p to £5.25
The total collectable per male playing member would therefore become £12.50 (a total increase of £1 compared to 2010) and payable to the Union within 90 days of the start of each Club’s subscription year. If new members are recruited in the six months following the calculation of this payment, a payment for these members will become due six months later.
There followed a discussion on the justification for these increases, a claim was made that this amounted to a 45% increase over 2 years and that if members knew what they were paying they would opt out.
The correct figure is that combined County and National subscriptions have risen from £10 in 2009 to the £12.50 proposed for 2011. 25% over two years, or 12.5 % per year.
Secretary pointed out that funding is needed to deal with the effective and efficient administration of golf in the County and the improved support for junior golfers and County teams. The programmes being implemented on clubs’ behalf have been explained and approved at other annual County meetings, the CGP AGM approved the targets for the Golf Partnership, the Junior Conference approved the County plans for Junior golfers’ support and Coaching. The County continues to be very cost conscious and seeks best value in all its transactions.
The President advised that in conversations with Presidents from other Counties throughout the country surprise was expressed that in Worcestershire there was opposition to raising money. He said that he found this lack of support very disappointing. One of the representatives advised that for the first time this year his Club had published details of the County and EGU subscriptions which had resulted in uproar.
The Secretary advised that all Clubs represented at the meeting had two votes and that there were therefore 48 Club votes. The 16 members of the Executive or honorary members of the County would have one vote each. Those present voted on the motion that the subscription payable to the WUGC for the year 2011 should increase by 75p to £7.25 and to confirm that the subscription payable to the EGU for the year 2011 will be £5.25.
Result: 47 votes in favour of the motion, 12 against. (17 Clubs in favour, 6 against) (one club representative was unable to stay until the time the voting took place)
The motion was therefore carried.
Mr Clive Werrett of The Vale asked that as the concerns of those speaking against the motion had been mainly budgetary, would it be possible for the Union to give consideration to any increase for 2012 as soon as possible so that Clubs could be notified early giving time for any increase to be incorporated into their budget?
Mr Edwards of Cocks Moor Woods asked whether it would be possible for the County to consider not charging a subscription for Juniors? The Secretary advised that the EGU had stated they are sympathetic to making this change, but that a reduction for Juniors would possibly have to be covered by an increase for adults. This is a point for discussion which comes up regularly at EGU meetings. Mr Graham Yardley of Hagley pointed out that the County Treasurer now has a breakdown of membership categories for all Clubs and that it should be possible to calculate what cost to the County such a move would mean.
The Secretary pointed out that the 25p increase for 2011 for the EGU was effectively a “standstill” figure and that the EGU have gone to all Counties asking how they should be funded in future. The response from Worcestershire will be that they would like to see more input from the PGA and closer alliance with all those who benefit from golf; manufacturers for example, Sky have an annual income from English Golf Clubs of over £6million whereas the EGU has an income of just over £4million.
The representative from Evesham asked whether the merger between the EGU and EWGA was going to take place and if so, will this reduce the level of bureaucracy and will the affiliation fees come down? The Secretary advised that the process is quite well advanced and is timetabled to be completed next Spring. Nothing will be finally agreed until all Clubs have had time to consider all the proposals and comment if appropriate. The Secretary advised that there did not look to be any insurmountable obstacles to the merger taking place.
14. Any Other Business: None
15. Date of Next Council Meeting: Tuesday 5 April 2011 at 6.30 p.m. at Moseley Golf Club.
There being no further business the meeting closed at 9.45 p.m.
|